Mexico snub throws Americas summit into disarray
June 7, 2022 04:52 PM
President Joe Biden's plan to reboot US engagement with Latin America -- especially on critical topics like migration -- took a hit after key partner Mexico snubbed a regional summit opening Monday in Los Angeles to protest Washington's exclusion of three far-left countries.
What was meant to be a week-long showcase of cooperation risks becoming a display of division, underlining diminishing US clout over a region where Washington's long-time economic and diplomatic influence faces a growing Chinese challenge.
A senior White House official confirmed that Cuba, Nicaragua and Venezuela were barred from the Summit of the Americas due to "lack of democratic space and the human rights situations."
In response, Mexican President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador said he too would stay away.
"You cannot have a Summit of the Americas if you do not have all the countries of the Americas attending," Lopez Obrador announced, complaining of US "hegemony" and "lack of respect for nations."
Although Foreign Minister Marcelo Ebrard will represent Mexico instead, the leftist populist leader's absence will diminish the impact of a summit where US-Mexico relations are at the heart of major immigration and trade issues.
The White House downplayed the spat, saying Biden was sticking up for principles, but that there was no bad blood between the neighbors.
"We do not believe that dictators should be invited," Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre told reporters.
But she noted that Lopez Obrador was set to visit Washington in July and said Biden had not been blindsided. "He was aware" ahead of the Mexican president's announcement, she said.
Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro said Monday that the US decision to exclude three nations' leaders from the summit was "an act of discrimination."
In Havana, the communist Cuban government issued a statement calling its exclusion "anti-democratic and arbitrary."
Biden, who flies to Los Angeles on Wednesday, will be announcing numerous "deliverables" at the summit, Jean-Pierre said.
The agenda on Wednesday will focus on regional economic and health issues, then climate change on Thursday.
Friday will be devoted to the surge of migration to the United States -- a major concern for US voters and an area where Republican opponents see Biden as vulnerable in upcoming midterm elections.
As the summit kicked off, another thousands-strong migrant caravan departed southern Mexico for the US border, with some chanting "Freedom!" and "We want visas!" as they started the 3,000-kilometer (1,860-mile) journey.
- Argentina, Brazil show up -
State Department spokesman Ned Price insisted that Lopez Obrador's absence did not doom the summit, praising Mexico as "an important hemispheric player."
The Biden administration said it had secured the presence of key regional players, including Argentina's left-leaning Alberto Fernandez and Brazil's Jair Bolsonaro.
Biden will have a bilateral meeting with Bolsonaro, a senior US official told reporters. The far-right Brazilian leader was previously close with Biden's predecessor Donald Trump, who attempted to overturn his election defeat in 2020.
Uruguay's President Luis Lacalle Pou was due to attend the summit, but canceled after contracting Covid-19, he tweeted Monday.
Benjamin Gedan, who heads the Latin America program at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, said Lopez Obrador's absence would mark a "significant void."
The snub has been "a really unfortunate subplot in the run-up to the summit because it has drained an enormous amount of US diplomatic energy for a bizarre cause celebre," Gedan said.
Biden has crafted a positive agenda, avoiding simply summoning Latin American leaders to lecture them on democracy, corruption and China, he said.
But, he added, it was unclear whether Biden will bring substantial resources to the table, in contrast to China's lavish infrastructure spending and trade privileges.
"I think, inevitably, the United States will disappoint," Gedan said.
- 'Progressively less ambitious' -
The Summit of the Americas is the first held by the United States since the inaugural 1994 meeting in Miami, where then-US president Bill Clinton sought the creation of a trade area to cover the whole continent except communist Cuba.
The United States has since soured on free trade, with Biden following the lead of Trump, who said such pacts hurt US workers.
Eric Farnsworth, vice president of the Council of the Americas, recently told a congressional hearing that each summit has become "progressively less ambitious."
Los Angeles, he said, "offers the perfect opportunity for Washington to announce a commitment to regional growth and recovery."
Michael Shifter, a senior fellow at the Inter-American Dialogue, said the drama over summit attendance showed Washington's waning hold over the region as China muscles in.
The United States "still has a lot of soft power," Shifter said. "As for political and diplomatic influence, it is diminishing by the day."