Lily Collins faces backlash over Audrey Hepburn biopic casting

The star of Netflix hit Emily in Paris, Lily Collins is facing a wave of online criticism after announcing she will portray screen legend Audrey Hepburn, a legendary British actress, fashion icon, and humanitarian, in an upcoming biopic.

Some fans argue, she is the wrong choice to embody the Hollywood icon.

The 36 year old actress revealed earlier this week that she has been cast in a film centered on the making of the 1961 classic Breakfast at Tiffany's.

The project is based on Fifth Avenue, 5 A.M., Audrey Hepburn, Breakfast at Tiffany's, and the Dawn of the Modern Woman by Sam Wasson, which explores the cultural impact and behind-the-scenes story of the beloved film.

According to reactions circulating on X and Reddit, some fans questioned whether Collins possesses the intangible charm many associate with Hepburn.

One critic wrote that physical resemblance alone is not enough, while another argued that the casting felt driven by aesthetics rather than depth.

Others suggested alternative names, including pop star and actress Ariana Grande, as a potentially better fit.

Skeptics also debated the film’s focus, with some social media users questioning whether the making of Breakfast at Tiffany’s is the most compelling chapter of Hepburn’s life to bring to the screen.

According to commenters, her humanitarian work and childhood experiences during World War II would make for a richer narrative.

Despite the backlash, Collins expressed deep admiration for the late actress in her announcement. She described the role as an honor and said the project has been years in development. The film remains untitled, and additional casting details have yet to be revealed.